When we started building our Coaching League community last month, we faced the same decision you're probably facing right now: Skool or Circle? Most comparisons you'll read are theoretical - but we actually had to make this choice for our real community, with real consequences.

Key Takeaways

🎯 Quick Decision Guide:

• Choose Skool if you want high engagement, simple setup, and plan to help members launch their own communities
• Choose Circle if you need deep customization, built-in video hosting, and advanced integrations

💰 Pricing:

• Skool: $99/month flat rate with unlimited members
• Circle: Starts at $49/month (100 members) to $199/month (10,000 members)

🚀 Main Differences:

• Skool: Single unified feed, strong gamification, simpler interface
• Circle: Multi-space system, native video hosting, advanced automation

Ready to get started?

• Try Skool free for 14 days → Try Skool
• Try Circle free for 14 days → Try Circle

In case you're in a hurry: We went with Skool. But keep reading, because that might not be the right choice for your specific needs. In fact, you can read my detailed Skool review here.

Our Decision Journey

We were building a community that needed to:

• Support our coaching programs
• Make it easy for members to engage daily
• Help our coaches eventually build their own communities
• Scale smoothly as we grow

The decision wasn't easy. Circle impressed us with some powerful technical features:

• It integrates perfectly with our Webflow site through Outseta
• Comes with built-in video hosting
• Offers detailed automation options
• Provides deep customization possibilities

But Skool caught our attention because:

• It's gaining massive adoption in the coaching space
• The interface is incredibly simple to use
• It has built-in gamification that actually works
• Members can easily launch their own communities

What's Actually at Stake

Choosing a community platform isn't just about comparing feature lists. Your choice will affect:

• How easily members engage with your content
• What technical limitations you'll face
• How smoothly you can scale
• Your daily workflow as a community leader

Here's something important we learned: Sometimes the platform with more features isn't the best choice for your community's success.

A Simple Decision Framework

If you're short on time, here's a straightforward way to choose...

Choose Skool if you:

• Want high member engagement
• Need a simple, easy-to-use platform
• Plan to help members create their own communities
• Prefer a unified community space

Choose Circle if you:

• Need specific technical integrations
• Want advanced automation options
• Require built-in video hosting
• Need deep customization options as well as groups and spaces

Who This Guide Is For

This comparison will be especially helpful if you're:

• Building a coaching or learning community
• Planning to launch within the next few months
• Trying to balance features vs. usability
• Looking for real, practical insights

Let's dive into the details of what each platform actually offers, starting with their core features...

What are the Key Features of Skool vs Circle?

Before we dive into specific features, it's worth noting that these platforms take fundamentally different approaches to community building. Let's break down what each one offers.

What does Skool offer for community building?

The first thing you'll notice about Skool is its simplicity. After spending three years in beta testing before its 2022 launch, Skool has focused on making everything straightforward and engaging, especially compared to Circle.

Skool is a platform where course creators host their student communities and course content in 1-place, with 1-login, and 1-search. In the past, this was done with a Facebook Group, and a learning management system (LMS). Skool puts the two together and gamifies it so it's engaging and fun.

– Sam Ovens, Founder of Skool.com

Core Features

• A single, unified feed where all community interaction happens
• Simple topic organization to keep discussions focused
• One-click sign-on across all Skool communities
• A discovery feature that helps members find relevant communities
• Basic course hosting with folders and pages structure, similar to tools like Kajabi.

Something worth noting: While Skool doesn't have built-in video hosting (you'll need to use Vimeo or similar), this actually keeps things running faster and simpler for most users.

Technical Foundation

• Mobile apps for both iOS and Android
• Integration options through Zapier and Webhooks
• Clean, unified interface that new members understand immediately
• 24/7 customer support team

How does Circle provide unique features?

Circle takes a more traditional but highly flexible approach. Currently valued at $200 million, they're focused on providing professional-grade features for serious community builders.

We're making a big push to be that all-in-one platform for your needs, and continue to get better at each aspect of the all-in-one part. Better payments, better discussions, better chat, better events, better courses!

– Sid Yadav, Founder of Circle.so

Core Features

• Multi-space system for organizing different types of content
• Native video hosting built right in
• Live streaming capabilities for events and webinars
• Customizable space layouts
• Full API access for custom development
• Automated workflows for community management

Technical Capabilities

• Create different spaces for courses, discussions, and events
• Choose different layout options for each space
• Advanced member search and filtering
• Embed community spaces on external websites

Comparing the community management tools of both platforms

This is where the real differences become clear:

Content Creation

Skool keeps it simple:

• Basic posting system that everyone understands
• Easy image sharing
• YouTube video embedding
• Straightforward polls

Circle offers more options:

• Rich text editor with advanced formatting
• Native video uploads
• Multiple image galleries
• File attachments
• Scheduled posts

Member Management

Both platforms handle this differently:

Skool focuses on community members and engagement features.

• Simple user profiles
• Basic member directory
• Activity-based recognition
• Community-wide visibility

Circle provides:

• Detailed member directories
• Advanced profile customization
• Granular permission systems
• Complex moderation tools

A key insight from our experience: The most important features aren't always the most complex ones. When we were choosing between the two, we realized that engagement and ease of use were more important for our coaching community than having every possible feature.

How Does Pricing Compare Between Skool and Circle?

Let's talk money - because pricing isn't just about the monthly fee, it's about what you actually get for your investment.

What is the pricing model for Skool?

Skool keeps it refreshingly simple with a flat-rate pricing model:

• $99 per month
• All features included
• Unlimited members
• No hidden fees
• 14-day free trial

What's interesting about Skool's pricing is that there are no tiers or complicated decisions to make. You get everything, regardless of your community size. This is particularly valuable if you're planning to grow your community significantly.

Circle's pricing structure explained

Circle takes a more traditional tiered approach:

Basic Plan: $49/month

• Limited to 100 members
• Basic community features
• No course or live streaming features
• Email support

Professional Plan: $99/month

• Up to 1000 members
• Course features included
• Live streaming capabilities
• Premium support

Business Plan: $219/month (when paid monthly, you can get it down to $199 by going with yearly)

• 10,000 members
• Advanced automation features
• Custom branding
• API access
• Priority support

All Circle plans include:

• 14-day free trial
• Monthly or annual billing (save with annual)
• Community AI features

Which platform offers better value for creators?

This is where it gets interesting, and we need to consider several factors:

For Small Communities (Under 100 members)

• Circle might seem cheaper at $49/month
• But Skool offers more features at this level
• No worry about hitting member limits with Skool

For Growing Communities (100-1000 members)

• Both platforms cost about the same ($99/month)
• Circle starts limiting some features
• Skool maintains all features regardless of size

For Large Communities (1000+ members)

• Skool maintains the $99/month price
• Circle requires the Business plan at $199/month
• Consider the value of Circle's advanced features

Hidden Costs to Consider

With Skool:

• External video hosting if needed (e.g., Vimeo)
• Any Zapier costs for advanced integrations

With Circle:

• Potential upgrade costs as you grow
• Additional integration costs
• Custom development if needed

The Real Value Consideration

Based on our experience, here's what really matters:

1. Growth Plans

• If you're planning rapid growth, Skool's unlimited model is very attractive
• If you need enterprise features, Circle's higher tiers might be worth it

2. Feature Needs

• If you need built-in video hosting, factor in external hosting costs with Skool
• If you need advanced automation, consider Circle's higher tier costs

3. Long-term Investment

• Skool's pricing is more predictable for long-term planning
• Circle might require upgrades as you grow, but comes with more features

A practical tip: Don't just look at the monthly fee. Consider what you'll need six months or a year from now, and factor in any additional tools you'll need to make either platform work for your specific situation.

What are the Integration Options Available for Each Platform?

Integration capabilities can make or break your community setup, especially if you're running a business that relies on multiple tools. Let's break down what each platform offers.

How does Skool integrate with third-party tools?

Skool takes a minimalist approach to integrations, which aligns with their "keep it simple" philosophy:

Current Integration Options

• Zapier integration for connecting with other apps
• Webhooks for custom connections
• Vimeo integration for video hosting
• Basic calendar integration (Google Calendar, Apple Calendar, etc.)

Common Integration Use Cases

• Connecting with email marketing platforms
• Syncing with payment processors
• Automating member management
• Linking with course platforms

Limitations to Consider

• No direct native integrations
• Relies heavily on Zapier for connections
• Limited API access currently
• No direct Webflow/Outseta integration

How does Circle integrate with third-party tools?

Like Skool, Circle also offers integration options but even more robust, especially for technical users who want to customize the experience. They really offer everything you need:

Native Integrations

• Direct Outseta integration
• Webflow compatibility through Outseta
• WordPress single sign-on
• Facebook/Twitter login options

API Access (Business Plan)

• Full API documentation
• Custom development options
• Webhook support
• Advanced automation possibilities

Third-Party Connections

• Zapier integration
• Multiple payment gateway options
• Email marketing platform connections
• Course platform integrations

Automation features in Skool and Circle

This is where we see some significant differences between the features of Skool and Circle.

Circle's Automation Capabilities

• Built-in workflow automation (higher tiers)
• Trigger-based actions like:
  • Welcome message automation
  • Member onboarding sequences
  • Engagement reminders
  • Content access rules
  • Tag-based automations

Skool's Automation Approach

• More basic automation options
• Relies on Zapier for most automation needs
• Common automations include:
  • Member welcome sequences
  • Point-based rewards
  • Activity notifications
  • Basic content access rules

Real-World Integration Considerations

From our experience setting up the Coaching League, here are some practical things to consider:

1. Essential Integrations

• What tools do you absolutely need to connect?
• Are you okay using Zapier as a middle-man?
• Do you need direct API access?

2. Technical Expertise Required

• Circle requires more technical knowledge for advanced integrations
• Skool's limited options actually make it simpler to manage
• Consider your team's technical capabilities

3. Future Needs

• Will you need more complex integrations as you grow?
• Are you planning to build custom features?
• How important is automation for your community?

A practical tip we learned: Make a list of your must-have integrations before choosing a platform. We initially thought we needed all of Circle's integration options, but realized Skool's simpler approach actually covered our core needs.

What is the User Experience Like on Skool vs Circle?

The user experience can make or break a community platform. Let's look at how both platforms handle this crucial aspect.

How intuitive is the user interface of Skool?

After spending time with Skool, it's clear why they spent three years in beta getting the user experience right.

Navigation System

• Single unified feed (like a social media platform)
• Clear topic organization without nested menus
• Everything is accessible within 1-2 clicks
• Mobile experience mirrors desktop functionality

Content Creation & Sharing

• One-click posting (similar to Facebook)
• Simple media uploads
• Easy YouTube video embedding
• Quick polls and questions
• Straightforward course access

What Users Love

• No learning curve for new members
• Familiar social media-like experience
• Clear notification system
• Easy to find and join conversations

Common Pain Points

• Limited content organization options
• No native video hosting (requires external links)
• Basic formatting options
• Can get busy in very active communities

Circle's user experience compared to Skool

Circle takes a more structured approach that offers more control but requires more learning.

Interface Design

• Multiple organized spaces
• Customizable layouts
• Separate areas for different content types
• Professional look and feel

Content Management

• Rich text editor with advanced formatting
• Native video uploading
• Multiple content organization options
• Scheduled posting capabilities

What Users Love

• Professional appearance
• Organized content spaces
• Advanced customization options
• Built-in course features

Common Pain Points

• Steeper learning curve
• Can feel overwhelming at first
• Multiple menus to navigate
• More clicks to accomplish tasks

Community members' feedback on both platforms

Let's look at what actual users are saying and the metrics that matter.

Engagement Metrics

Circle's benchmark data shows:

• Communities with 100-500 members: 60% monthly active users
• Communities with 500-1000 members: 40% monthly active users
• Communities with 1000+ members: 30% monthly active users
• Top communities see 80% of posts from members (not admins)

For reference, Circle considers:

• Under 2.5% churn: Exceptional
• 5% churn: Excellent
• 10% churn: Average
• Over 15% churn: Needs improvement

Real User Feedback Patterns

Skool users often mention:

• "Feels like using social media"
• "Easy to jump right in"
• "Gamification keeps me coming back"
• "Simple but sometimes too simple"

Circle users frequently note:

• "Professional and polished"
• "Great for organized content"
• "Takes time to learn"
• "Powerful but complex"

Our Experience Building the Coaching League

A few key insights from our journey:

1. Initial Setup

• Skool took hours to set up
• Circle would have taken days to configure properly

2. Member Onboarding

• New members instantly understand Skool
• Less time spent explaining how to use the platform
• Fewer support questions about navigation

3. Daily Management

• Simpler to maintain on Skool
• Fewer technical questions from members
• More natural engagement

A practical tip: Consider your community members' tech-savviness when choosing. We found that Skool's simpler approach meant more members actually participated, even if we had to give up some advanced features.

How Do Gamification and Engagement Features Differ?

This is where Skool and Circle take radically different approaches to keeping members active and engaged. Let's break down how each platform handles this crucial aspect of community building.

What gamification elements does Skool provide?

Skool has made gamification a core part of their platform, and it shows in their feature set.

Points System

• 1 like = 1 point
• Points accumulate to unlock levels
• Progress bar shows path to next level
• Point history visible on profiles, a feature that enhances community member interaction.

Levels and Rewards

• Customizable level thresholds
• Ability to unlock content based on levels
• Access special features at higher levels
• Recognition for top contributors

Practical Applications

We've seen these work well for:

• Encouraging daily participation
• Driving meaningful interactions
• Creating friendly competition
• Rewarding active members

For example, in our Coaching League, we use levels to:

• Unlock access to premium resources
• Grant special community privileges
• Recognize expertise and contribution
• Create natural community leaders

Circle's approach to boosting engagement

Circle takes a more traditional but data-driven approach to engagement.

Activity Scoring System

• Tracks member participation
• Measures contribution quality
• Monitors connection building
• Benchmarks against other communities

Engagement Tools

• Automated welcome sequences
• Custom member onboarding
• Space-specific engagement tracking
• Member recognition features

Analytics and Insights

Circle provides detailed metrics showing:

• Monthly Active User rates (varying by community size)
  • 60% for communities of 100-500 members
  • 40% for communities of 500-1000
  • 30% for larger communities
• Content creation ratios (80% member content in top communities)
• Churn rate benchmarks

Can these features enhance community building?

Based on real-world experience and platform data, here's what actually works:

Skool's Impact

1. Immediate Engagement

• Members start participating on day one
• Clear rewards for contribution
• Visible progress motivates action
• Natural community hierarchy develops

2. Long-term Benefits

• Sustained participation rates
• Member-driven content creation
• Natural community leaders emerge
• Reduced need for admin intervention

Circle's Impact

1. Professional Growth

• Data-driven engagement strategies
• Structured participation
• Clear success metrics
• Professional networking opportunities for community members.

2. Measurable Results

• Detailed engagement analytics
• Clear ROI measurements
• Churn prediction capabilities
• Performance benchmarking

Practical Considerations for Your Community

Choose Skool's gamification if you want:

• Immediate, visible engagement
• Self-sustaining member motivation
• Fun, social media-like interaction
• Community-driven growth

Choose Circle's approach if you need:

• Professional engagement metrics
• Structured member progression
• Detailed analytics
• Corporate-style networking

A key insight from our experience: While Circle offers more sophisticated tracking, Skool's simple gamification often drives more actual engagement. Members don't need to understand how it works - they just naturally want to participate.

What Community Management Tools are Offered?

Let's dive into the tools that actually help you run and grow your community day-to-day. This is crucial stuff that directly impacts how much time you'll spend managing your community.

Skool's community management tools explained

Content Management

• Post scheduling: Currently limited
• Content organization: Topic-based
• Media handling:
  • Image uploads
  • YouTube embeds
  • External video links (Vimeo recommended)
  • File sharing capabilities

Moderation Features

• Basic post moderation
• Comment management features like those found in Slack.
• Member muting options
• Simple reporting system

Analytics and Insights

• Member activity tracking
• Engagement statistics
• Point system tracking
• Level progression metrics

Administrative Tools

• Member management dashboard
• Basic access controls
• Topic creation and management
• Settings configuration

Circle's member directories and rich member profiles

Directory Capabilities

• Advanced member search
• Custom filter options
• Tag-based organization
• Professional networking features

Profile Features

• Customizable profile fields
• Activity history
• Contribution tracking
• Connection management
• Professional details

Management Features

• Detailed member analytics
• Custom tagging system
• Group organization
• Access level management

How to host live events on Skool and Circle

Circle's Live Event Features

• Native live streaming
• Event scheduling
• Registration management
• Recording capabilities
• Live chat during events
• Event analytics
• Calendar integration

Skool's Event Approach

• External tool integration required
• Basic event announcement features
• Calendar sync options
• Community discussion spaces for events

Practical Event Management Tips

For Circle:

• Plan events directly in the platform
• Use native streaming for simpler events
• Leverage recording features for content library
• Track attendance and engagement

For Skool:

• Integrate with Zoom or similar platforms
• Use topics for event discussions
• Create dedicated event spaces
• Focus on community engagement around events

Real-World Management Insights

From our experience running the Coaching League, here are some key observations:

Daily Management Tasks

Skool makes it easier to:

• Monitor general engagement
• Respond to member interactions
• Track member progress
• Maintain community momentum

Circle excels at:

• Organizing structured content
• Managing complex permissions
• Tracking detailed metrics
• Handling professional events

Time Investment

1. Content Management

• Skool: ~30% less time due to simplicity
• Circle: More time upfront, but better organization

2. Member Management

• Skool: More intuitive, less hand-holding needed
• Circle: More powerful tools, but requires more setup

3. Event Management

• Skool: Requires external tool integration
• Circle: More complete built-in solution

A practical tip we learned: While Circle offers more management features, Skool's simplicity often means spending less time on management and more time on actual community building.

Making Your Final Choice: Skool vs Circle in 2024

Let's bring this all together and help you make the right choice for your community.

Platform Choice Framework

Use Case Considerations

Ask yourself these key questions:

1. Community Type

• Are you building a coaching community?
• Is it primarily for courses?
• Do you need professional networking?
• How important is casual interaction?

2. Member Profile

• How tech-savvy are your members?
• Do they prefer simple or feature-rich platforms?
• Are they likely to engage daily?
• Will they need to launch their own communities?

3. Content Delivery

• Do you need built-in video hosting?
• How much content organization do you require?
• Will you host live events frequently?
• Do you need complex course structures?

Budget Factors

Consider your total costs:

1. Direct Platform Costs

• Skool: Flat $99/month
• Circle: $49-$199/month based on needs

2. Additional Tools Needed

• Video hosting (for Skool)
• Integration tools (Zapier, etc.)
• External event platforms
• Marketing tools

3. Long-term Investment

• Growth-related costs
• Upgrade requirements
• Integration expenses
• Training time

Technical Requirements

Evaluate your technical needs:

1. Essential Integrations

• Website platforms (Webflow, WordPress)
• Payment systems
• Email marketing
• Analytics tools

2. Customization Needs

• Branding requirements
• Custom features
• API access
• Automation needs

Growth Plans

Think about your future:

1. Community Size

• Expected member growth
• Content scaling
• Team expansion
• Resource requirements

2. Feature Needs

• Future functionality
• Platform limitations
• Scaling capabilities
• Integration requirements

Final Recommendations

Choose Skool When:

✓ You value engagement over complexity ✓ Your community needs quick adoption ✓ Members might create their own communities ✓ You prefer simple, unified spaces ✓ Daily engagement is crucial ✓ Budget predictability matters ✓ You're building a coaching community

Choose Circle When:

✓ You need deep customization ✓ Professional features are essential ✓ Built-in video hosting is required ✓ Complex integrations are necessary ✓ You need detailed analytics ✓ Enterprise features are important ✓ You're building a professional network

Migration Considerations

If you're switching platforms:

1. Plan for:

• Content migration
• Member transition
• Integration updates
• Training time

2. Consider:

• Data export options
• Member communication
• Transition timeline
• Resource allocation

Future Outlook

Looking ahead to 2024-2025:

Skool's Trajectory:

• Growing marketplace presence
• Increasing adoption rates
• Planned video hosting features
• Expanding integration options

Circle's Direction:

• Enhanced enterprise features
• Improved automation capabilities
• Deeper integration ecosystem
• Advanced analytics tools

Final Thoughts

After analyzing both platforms extensively for our Coaching League community, here's our bottom line:

Don't choose based on features alone. Choose based on how your community will actually use the platform daily. For us, Skool's simplicity and engagement features won over Circle's advanced capabilities.

Remember: The best platform isn't the one with the most features – it's the one that best serves your specific community needs.

A Final Tip: Whichever platform you choose, focus on building genuine connections first. The technology should facilitate community building, not complicate it.

‍